By Robert Granader
“A notice period!” Reggie shouted to an empty room. “Are you kidding me?”
He was alone in his den, reading through the final bills from the Sunset Village Retirement Complex. A stack of condolence cards lay unread on the side of his desk.
“Sharon,” he screamed into the next room. “When do we need to clean out my parents’ place?”
His wife rushed in; she’d worn out the carpet coming into his den when he shouted and leaving again when he steamed.
“There’s no rush,” Sharon said. “There’s a three-month cancellation window.”
“A cancellation period,” he repeated. “When should we have put in notice, when she went into hospice?”
Sharon ignored him and exited.
Over the previous few months, Sharon rarely stepped in to hear the completion of his rants. She’d learned, in the weeks and months before and since his parents’ passing, that Reggie’s top emotion was not sadness but frustration, followed by anger, and often she was the family sponge for it.
He was more critical than usual. Everything from problems with the food to criticism of the mourners, nitpicking at the children, anger at the skies that the sun either shined too brightly or didn’t at all. He seemed mad at the universe that this was where he had landed. It was his turn to be the son mourning the parents. An orphan at age fifty-eight. It was his time to be the next generation, even though it had been happening slowly for decades. He just didn’t see it hitting this hard.
The pain of the previous week’s events dissolved into three parts anger, two parts frustration, and one part mourning.
“There is a business to death,” he said quietly to himself. “The casket, the graveyard, do you tip the diggers? The clergy? Everybody has their hand out.”
“Will you look at this!” he screamed. “There’s a minimum!”
She ran back in. “To what?”
“There’s a food minimum,” he said. “My mother hadn’t had a full meal in ten years, and all this time she’s had a monthly food minimum, like it’s a country club.”
“I’m sure it’s standard,” Sharon said, doing nothing to pacify him.
“There’s a food minimum during the cancellation period,” his voice rising. “That means we need to pay for three months of food while she’s in the ground?”
“Why not send it to Hal and see what he says,” Sharon said, referring to their family attorney.
Soon Reggie was on the phone with Ms. Hilty, caretaker of Sunset Hills. His voice went up, almost cracking. He was raging at the heavens—not Ms. Hilty, not the lawyers, not the contract; it was everything.
But in the end his mother was dead either way, and this was how he lashed out, with loud voices at people who couldn’t solve his problems.
What set off this cascade of emotion was the untimely alarm on his phone. It was three days into shiva, the week-long Jewish mourning period, and his phone dinged. It was his monthly reminder to pay his mother’s bills. A reminder he’d set years ago when he took over the responsibility of his parents’ finances. But now it was worthless; time to shut it down. This would end, like so many things that ended when she took her final breath.
That ding came the first Wednesday of the month for the past ten years, and it was a reminder not just to pay the bill but to call or visit. His parents had plenty of money, and so his check of the bills took on a familiar perusal. The bills rarely varied; there was a cost for the room, an association expense, food overruns.
But now, scanning the “final” bill, he steamed over the things he’d never noticed and now seemed unfair.
“This is a scam,” he said to himself. “It’s all just a business, everything is just a business.”
He understood about final bills. He knew that subscriptions don’t end when people die, collectors don’t disappear, horror stories abound.
“These are the perfect scams,” he said, digging deep into the internet for confirmation. “It’s a he said/she said, and one of the saids is dead!”
Sharon was in bed, doing a crossword puzzle online, when he came into their room.
“Look at this,” he said, a stack of papers in one hand and his phone in the other. “This article is all about how nursing homes scamming dementia patients.”
“At Sunset Village?” she asked.
“No, this happened in North Carolina, but it’s the perfect crime,” he said. “Charging people with no memory for things they may or may not have ordered. They can’t get away with this.”
Sharon looked up from her puzzle.
“This has to stop,” she said. “Let’s assume you are correct, that there is this vast conspiracy to bilk old people with memory loss and that they get into this business for the lucrative gambit of charging for extra food. So what?”
In the end all of the things he wanted to challenge were in the contract:
- There was a three-month period after his mother died where they would have to pay for her room, clean-up, and disposal.
- A food minimum was included during that time.
- Everything was prepaid.
In the early days of what he called “their captivity” at Sunset Village, he was a frequent visitor, happy to have them out of their stair-filled, sharp-edged house. But as they got older, the vacant look crept into their eyes, the boredom he thought he saw, and his time between visits spread.
For a moment he lamented not seeing his mother in her final months, but his lack of visits, he convinced himself, was not from a lack of love. There was such a sadness to it all. The quiet days staring at the walls. He imagined all the hours as a series of boredom combatants. How unpleasant everything looked to him, from the painting classes to the meals and the food; he couldn’t imagine the taste of the food.
Ms. Hilty—the CFO of Death, as he called her—had been the recipient of his ire for some time, well before either parent got sick. It started years before with a late-day call when she asked if they could speak privately.
He assumed one of his parents got a bad medical test result or wasn’t taking their medication.
“Our actuarial tables tell us your mother is living longer than expected,” was how Ms. Hilty started the conversation.
“And it works better for your business if she dies younger?” Reggie said.
“No, of course not,” she stumbled before righting herself and saying, “We love your mother, like we love all our residents. So well-liked by so many people.”
“But you’d like her to die,” he said.
“Oh God no, we hope she continues to lead a productive life.” Ms. Hilty was clearly reading off a script. “But she is outliving, or could outlive, her bank account, or at least the accounts that we see. And so we’d like, or rather, we’ll need some assurances, some backup, some guarantees.”
“You want to make sure you’re getting paid,” he said.
“You’re a businessman, Mr. Freed, you can understand.”
And of course he could, but there was something about the way she went about it. Something about the euphemisms and the questions where the answers were known. His father still handled all the family bills at that point, and so Reggie wasn’t privy to the extent of the financial proctology exam they went through—their bank accounts, insurance policies, their income levels—and what that meant for acceptance to Sunset Village.
Outliving your money is bad for business, and evidently his mother was getting a bit too close for their comfort.
So when she died Reggie wanted to say, “See, Ms. Hilty, your actuarial tables were wrong, she died in time.”
“Would that be helpful?” Sharon asked, when he explained his plan to “rub it in Ms. Hilty’s face.”
Ms. Hilty was the reason he went there so infrequently; he could tell himself. It wasn’t fear of death, or the smell, or the memories of his father in his waning days. It was the garbage and the bureaucracy and all the paperwork that went into keeping his parents alive and fed and their days filled.
He thought about all the things that animated his life, from work to his wife and kids, golf on the weekends, the shows they’d watch. His life was rich and full, just as his parents’ had been at one time. It wasn’t that his parents’ death was a mortality reminder, it was that their empty lives drove a fear deep into him of what old age might become. He wasn’t like his mother. She was happy and smiley in her youth, as a young mother, as a grandmother, and as she faded into old age, she remained that same person.
But he was his father, and he knew he had a darkness that followed him. A darkness that made even sunny days difficult when he was irritable, frustrated, angry. But mostly he was scared. Of something, the world, sickness; maybe it wasn’t even anything specific, just something deep in his amygdala was telling him to watch out.
And all this swirled in his head in the mornings before he made it out of bed and in the evenings before he fell into his fitful sleeps, but during his day his mind was cleaned by the real or imagined activities that occupied his mind so he wouldn’t have time to dwell on “the troubles,” as his wife called them.
So, he imagined his parents’ world. A space where he couldn’t fill his day with all the things that clogged his mind and ate up the worries. He feared retirement or the dormant life would be like the dread of his mornings and his nights. He could never tell anyone, but this was why he worked so much and so long. Most of his friends seemed to love the nighttime when their wives were out. The night to do whatever you wanted. But he dreaded the quiet. If Sharon was out playing cards or at dinner with girlfriends, he’d stay late at the office or go to a bar and have a drink with a game on the television. An empty house felt sad.
When he did see his parents, they talked about a lifestyle that suited them, but he was sure it was a façade. In his final years his dad would recount his day to Reggie, telling him about the doctor visits, the chess games, the books he’d read, and Reggie thought he was just filling time. His father would announce his excitement about the day, all the things he’d accomplish before he took his post-lunch nap.
Thrilling.
At breakfast the following morning, Reggie was quiet.
“Are you going to argue over the three-dollar extra food charge?” Sharon asked, breaking the silence.
“I would but I’m screwed,” he said. “The system is fixed, I can’t break in. This last bill is filled with charges that of course I can’t verify. Did my mother ask for an electric blanket in her last days? I have no idea. So they charge her for the blanket and extra nighttime electricity.”
“Let it go,” she said. “Do you want me to pay them so you don’t have to see it?”
“It’s prepaid,” he shouted, “even the food minimum.”
“Well, then head over there and gobble up the buffet and get your money’s worth,” she said.
“Yes,” he said, “yes, yes, yes!”
“You are not going to use your mother’s food minimum,” she said.
“Oh yes I am,” he said. “You’ve wanted to go out to dinner. Well, it’s all you can eat, baby.”
“No,” she said.
“Dinner tonight, it’s on my mom,” he said.
“We’re eating Jell-O at Sunset Village?” she asked.
“For these prices they need to do better than Jell-O,” he said.
“I’m not eating there,” she said.
“You won’t believe this but they do takeout,” he said, pointing to a menu on his phone.
Pulling into the parking lot for the first time since what he thought was the last time, he felt something stir in his belly. By habit he looked toward the end window on the right side of the building, fifth floor, his parents’ room. The light was on and it made him wonder, in the way a child wonders, that some trick of the brain or miracle might occur, and he was wrong about everything. Although he hadn’t seen the body, he knew she was dead. Everything from the doctor, the coroner, the funeral home, those couldn’t be faked; she wasn’t in that room waiting for him. But the mind plays tricks.
The café, as it was called, was on the first floor, and while he felt a pull to the elevator, he cruised past the front desk and followed the line toward dinner.
“Oh, Mr. Freed.” A broad Jamaican woman with a perpetual smile stopped him. She had been working the front desk since he could remember. This woman was made for this place: she wasn’t good at being sad or trying to look sad, she oozed happiness. Even Reggie could feel that.
She surprised him by coming out from behind the desk to embrace him in a hug filled with real emotion. He knew this because it affected him, although he knew it must have been perfunctory, as she must do this every time a person dies.
“Thank you,” he said, his voice catching.
“I think we have someone taking care of the room,” she said.
“Yeah, uh, no, I’m not here to see my mom,” he said before catching himself. “I mean her room, yeah, I can’t do that, thanks so much, thanks. I’m just here for some food.”
He even felt stupid saying it.
Sharon was right, he thought. Nobody would be in this business solely to make money and screw old people. Would you really spend your time and effort cleaning out dead people’s rooms day after day just so you could overcharge them for extra toiletries?
The take-out window was at the far end of the cafeteria, requiring him to walk the length of the floor. Sitting on an old wooden shelf was a brown bag with cardboard handles with his mother’s name written across it. He reached for it and someone out of sight beyond the counter said, “Thanks, Rebecca.”
“I’m not,” he said hesitantly, “I mean obviously.”
“Oh, I’m sorry,” said a large woman with an even larger Afro caged in by a hairnet who was just coming into visibility. “Can I help?”
“No, I just mean Rebecca was my mother and she’s gone,” he said.
“They didn’t tell me the food was for the family, I’m so sorry,” she said. “Let me see your bill. We usually comp the family when they are in bereavement.”
“Bereavement? No, I don’t think we qualify, she died last week,” he said, “but there was still credit for the food, so I thought.”
Her confused look told him everything he needed to know. Nobody else did this. Ever. Nobody came and used up the dead person’s minimum. Either it was a huge scam that no one realized, or he was just an animal for doing it.
“She still has money on her account,” he said before grabbing the bag and hurrying off through the cafeteria and out to his car.
Sharon and Reggie were both surprised by the menu, its variety and quality, raising their eyebrows at how good the stir-fry was.
His energy behind squeezing every dollar out of Sunset Village faded over time, and that, coupled with his embarrassment as clearly being the only son to ever eat through his mother’s remaining food minimum, made him feel this was a one-and-done.
Days later he was in his office midday and unable to work. He wanted to be done with grieving. He kept telling himself to move on. He didn’t feel any overwhelming sadness, but he had to admit he was unproductive. God, he was unproductive. He’d look up and an hour had passed, and he hadn’t finished a single document, an email, or remembered what he was trying to do. And this was a day like that, nothing was getting done. Usually he’d walk the half mile to the salad place, assuming he just needed to get some blood pumping. But nothing was working and he’d had the same salad three days in a row. He scrolled through his phone and saw an email with another statement from Sunset Village. He opened it and saw a reduction in the food minimum. He clicked on the link and the menu popped open.
Of course they served lunch, he thought. He ordered online and headed to Sunset Village.
Embarrassment again set in. He looked down as he walked through the vestibule, just trying to get his food, but as he approached the take-away counter, it wasn’t there.
Fumbling through the app, he tried to show the kind-eyed woman his order until she said, “Ahhhh, I see. We have your order but you didn’t check the ‘to go’ button.”
“So what does that mean?”
“We have you set up at table twelve,” she said.
The air left his body. He needed to escape, eyeing the exits. This wasn’t what he planned on. His food was on the table, his name attached to a small stand. He half-smiled at his predicament and what this whole thing had gotten him. Picturing his parents sitting in the corner, watching and laughing how his emotion got the best of him again. He pulled his AirPods from his pocket and plugged in well before he reached his seat.
He pressed play just so something was going on in his head, his eyes on his food.
Even though it was delicious, he ate quickly and stood to leave. The sound of his squeaking chair turned a group of heads down the row from him. Three women and one man looked at him through their glasses and squints.
Hurrying past, a hand reached out and startled him. He stopped.
“Aren’t you Joe and Rebecca’s boy?” the man said.
“I am,” he replied, unsure of whom he was speaking with.
“I used to play chess with your dad,” he said. The old man struggled to stand.
Reggie helped him while urging him not to get up.
But the man rose. “He was a helluva player,” he said, “up till the end.”
“Thanks. I didn’t know he could still play, I mean with the memory thing and everything,” Reggie said before hurrying for the door.
* * *
“Are you ready for dinner with somebody other than me?” Sharon asked him later that night over dinner. His interest in other people and mindless pitter-patter of talking about the weather and sports with old friends infuriated him, but now it made him sad as well.
“I don’t think so,” he said. “I’m just not ready for that kind of socializing, you know, the bullshit.”
“I get it,” she said. “The Reynoldses want to come by later tonight. You up for a drink with them?”
“That’s fine,” he said, pushing his food around the corners of his plate.
“Why aren’t you eating?”
“Big lunch,” he said. “Oh, I didn’t tell you, I went by Sunset Village today.”
“For lunch? To make good carryout is a real art,” she said.
“Actually, I ate in.”
“Really?”
“I didn’t mean to but they’d already set up the table.”
“You ate alone?”
“Actually, this couple who knew my parents talked to me for a bit. He played chess with my dad.”
Later that week they pulled into the Sunset Village parking lot.
“We don’t have to do this,” he said.
“No, I want to,” she said in a tone that wasn’t very convincing.
They marched in together, past the front desk, where they were outfitted with name tags, and they sat at a table with a paper tablecloth and a flower in a vase strung together with a pipe cleaner.
“Fancy,” she said quietly but smiled at him. “Good to be out.”
They arrived closer to 7 p.m., assuming the myth that old people eat early and that it would have been cleared out by then. The Friday-night crowd was festive and dressed in their finest for the evening out, colorful dresses and men with three buttons open on their shirts.
As he and Sharon sat quietly, the place erupted in laughter and discussion.
“Pretty loud,” Sharon said.
“Because they’re all deaf,” he said.
They were shouting and they all had visible hearing aids dangling from their ears, but they were enjoying it.
“Who wants tequila?” someone shouted from the back. Reggie looked to see an employee making margueritas in colorful glasses with multicolored salt around the rim.
Another staffer pulled out hats and a sign that read Welcome to Margaritaville.
“It’s Cinco de Mayo,” Sharon said.
“They can’t feed these folks tequila, can they? It screams broken hips.”
And then, before she could answer, two residents dressed in shiny shoes got up to dance. The room smelled of tequila, the decorations screamed 1950s Cuba, and the music blared in tune.
These people weren’t bored and unhappy in an empty string of meals and chess games, Reggie thought. Whatever their lives were at this point, it was enough. There was less time to fill because of naps and sapped energy, but still this room was joyful, and he wondered whether his parents were this happy.
He didn’t feel like dancing, and besides, most Jews didn’t attend dances and happy occasions for up to a year after losing a parent. But he didn’t know he was attending a party. His attempt to extract some revenge on the CFO of Death for having a food minimum for dead people was highjacked by a Jimmy Buffett concert.
They finished their meal amid the din and just sat, watching the activity.
In bed later that night, Sharon asked Reggie if he was ready to start branching out, seeing other people “our own age.”
“Not yet,” he said.
The next day he received a notice that they’d met their food minimum, and he’d be charged for any “overages.”
“They get you whether you use the minimum or not,” he said.
“How about one last meal?” he asked Sharon on the final day of the month.
“I don’t really feel like it,” she said. “Can we carry out?”
“If you place the order,” he said, “I’ll pick up.”
When he arrived, he no longer looked toward his parents’ room. Instead, his eyes were on the dining room, to see how busy it was, who was eating, whether there was a line at carryout.
“Hi, Mr. F,” Sarah said at the front desk.
“Howdy, Mr. F,” Gerry said from behind the take-out counter.
“You’re over on your minimum, you know,” Gerry said as she checked him out.
“I know,” he said, smiling. “This is the last meal, I promise.”
“Is Mrs. F with you?” she asked.
“No, keep hers wrapped, I’ll just eat mine real quick,” he said.
She uncovered his food and dressed up his plate. He carried it, along with the bag with Sharon’s dinner, to a table.
Looking down to pick up his fork, a large sadness overtook him as he realized this was the last time he would stick a fork in his food in this place where his parents ate their final meals. This was the last supper. If anyone asked, he wouldn’t be able to explain; he just felt like crying. He wanted his parents like a child wants his parents when they are away, or when he is scared, or when someone has been mean to him. He blinked away the tears.
The sound of the tinfoil coming off a plate brought him back to the moment, this table, this meal. He hadn’t noticed an old man with an angular face sat down beside him, and he was opening Sharon’s dinner.
Reggie looked at the man, who was digging through the bag, searching for utensils. Too surprised to say anything, he just watched.
“You Joe’s son?” the man asked as he stuck his spoon in the soup.
“I am,” Reggie said, unable to ask the man why he was eating his wife’s meal.
“That man loved the Detroit Lions,” the man said.
“He did,” Reggie said.
“And they stunk,” the man said loudly and then laughed at himself.
“Remind me your name?” Reggie asked.
“Mo,” he said. “We’ve met before.”
“Of course,” Reggie said, although he had no recollection of him.
“You know they’re dead,” Mo said.
“I know,” Reggie said.
“Why didn’t you visit when they were alive?”
Reggie looked down at his plate. Normally he would be annoyed to the point of walking away from this question. But in the state he was in, mourning the end of so much, he sat there and took the abuse.
“I don’t know,” Reggie said. “I guess I just didn’t want to see them sick at the end.”
“Bullshit,” Mo announced. “You didn’t come before they got real sick.”
“I know,” Reggie said. “I didn’t come.”
“No, you didn’t,” Mo said.
“It made me sad,” Reggie said.
“To see your parents old?” Mo asked.
“No, it wasn’t them. It was me. I know that now,” he said. “I know our job is to grow old.”
“Better than the alternative,” Mo said, jumping in without looking at Reggie.
“Yep, better than the alternative, but when I saw this place, I wondered why grow old? Why am I going to grow old and watch my body droop, my children make mistakes, our lives get smaller? He and my mom would fight, and I’d wonder, is this winning?”
“They wouldn’t fight,” Mo said. “They’d bicker about stilly stuff, but you know what? They knew it was small stuff.”
Reggie nodded and moved his food around his plate.
“Our lives might look small to you,” Mo said. “And it is. But we are happy with it. We have friends and activities and it’s enough. I don’t want to go out past nine at night because I get tired. I like being home. This home. I want to get back to my room and my books and my memories.”
“I didn’t know,” he said, “I just thought—”
“But you didn’t ask if we were happy, if they were” Mo said. “Everyone looks at us like we are sad but we aren’t. Yes, there’s been sadness over the years. I miss my friends. I miss my Maria. I miss my dog, the toy collie I grew up with back in Ohio. I miss parts of being young, but I don’t want to be young. I don’t want to have your worries. When you get older and things close in on you, you want simplicity. You want no pain. You want to no frustration. Sometimes you know what you want. Sometimes you just want a good cup of soup.”
“And you find that here?” Reggie asked.
“In spades,” he said. “Have you had the soup?”
Reggie smiled as Mo slurped down Sharon’s soup. He closed his eyes as he prepared to walk away from this place, this smell, this food, those curtains. He knew he would never be back and that he couldn’t change the last months of his parents’ lives. He knew that all the things he couldn’t talk about with his parents were, in fact, things he could talk about. They were laid out there for him to ask, but he didn’t find a way. It was his fears, not theirs. All those years of not talking about getting old, when they would have told him that life was pretty good.
Now he knew.
“Thanks, Mo,” he said, rising slowly from the table. “It’s getting late.”
Mo startled Reggie by putting his hand on his.
“It’s not late,” he said. “There’s plenty of fun left.”
Robert Granader’s work has been featured in the Washington Post, Washingtonian magazine, The New York Times, Blue Lake Review, borrowed solace, Doubly Mad: A Journal of Arts and Ideas, Gris-Gris, Front Porch Review, Isele Magazine, The MacGuffin, Mariashriver.com, Open Ceilings, Pennsylvania English, riverSedge: A Journal of Art and Literature, and Umbrella Factory. He has won writing awards from Bethesda Magazine and Writer’s Digest. In 2022, he published a collection of his short stories, Writing in the Q. He has attended various workshops at the Writer’s Center in Bethesda, Maryland, as well as the Key West Literary Seminar and Writer’s Digest Conference in Los Angeles. He has a bachelor’s degree in English from the University of Michigan and a Juris Doctorate degree from The George Washington University. He has published more than 400 short stories, articles, and essays in over sixty publications and is now the CEO of Marketresearch.com.